← Seth Putnam

Is cereal soup?

June 27, 2025 · originally on Shelter

You know the kind: What do you do, when did you move here, how about this weather, what are the ins and outs of Liam’s travel baseball schedule?

The only thing smaller than the talk is my interest. Spare me, I beg you.

I am spiritually united in my grouchiness with Mrs. Matthiessen, whose very French list of Seven Things You’re Not Supposed to Talk About should be gospel. The list includes: diet, common ailments, how you slept, and longwinded explanations of how you got where you were going. (It also includes money, which is where I dissent; we should all be talking a lot more about that, actually.)

Here is a list of increasingly unhinged “medium talk” questions that I like to turn to when meeting new parents in the neighborhood. Just invasive enough to throw someone off balance when deployed in what you’d expect to be a small-talk conversation. The goal here, obviously, is to scare them off (ideally) or identify (grudgingly) who might be a kindred spirit.

Here’s your homework:

  1. Reply back or comment with the “medium talk” questions in your own arsenal.

  2. Answer your favorite question above — or as many as you’d like. I genuinely would like to know!

away we go.


Shelter by Seth Putnam is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.


Cars lined up outside Suwa Taisha shrine, including a Nissan GT-R (left), 1967 Alfa Romeo Giulia 1300GT (centre) and a classic Porsche 911 (second from right)

Forget the bullet train – the best way to see Japan is by classic car

By David Coggins for Financial Times


Every Year This New York Family of 5 Does Summer Camps in Europe. Here’s How They Pull It Off by Terry Ward for AFAR

What They’re Gossiping (And Complaining) About in the Hamptons by Stephanie Krikorian for Curbed

10 ways you can help kill Mike Lee’s land grab by Travis Hall for Field & Stream


home tour

opposite the dining area is a small but fully functional kitchen. the ladderbac 19

Overbrook Overlook: An Architect’s Barn-Turned-Tiny Home ‘Operates Much Bigger Than It Is’

By Fan Winston for Remodelista


Seth Putnam is an editor and writer in Chicago. He lives with his wife, son, and daughter in a 1920s home that is the epitome of a work in progress.


"Instructions for living a life: Pay attention. Be astonished. Tell about it." —Mary Oliver